CNBC: Trump said tariffs could someday ‘substantially replace’ income taxes. What policy experts say

CNBC: Trump said tariffs could someday ‘substantially replace’ income taxes. What policy experts say

 https://www.cnbc.com/2026/02/27/trump-tariffs-income-taxes.html

=============

ChatGPT: Theoretically, is that possible? Are there countries that do not have taxes because of either natural resources or tourism provide enough income?

Theoretically, a country could fund its government without income taxes — but only under specific economic conditions. For a large, complex economy like the United States, replacing income taxes with tariffs alone is extremely unlikely.

Let’s break this into two parts:

---

1️⃣ Could tariffs replace income taxes in theory?

In theory, yes — but only if:

• The government is relatively small (low spending as a % of GDP).

• Imports are extremely large relative to the economy.

• Tariff rates are very high.

• Trade does not collapse in response to those tariffs.

Why it worked in early U.S. history

Before the modern income tax was introduced in 1913, the U.S. government relied heavily on tariffs. But:

• Federal spending was tiny (around 2–3% of GDP).

• There were no large entitlement programs (no Social Security, Medicare, etc.).

• The federal government did far fewer things than today.

Today, U.S. federal spending is around 20%+ of GDP. The math is dramatically different.

The core economic problem

Tariffs are applied to imports.
Income taxes are applied to income, which is a much larger base.

If tariffs are raised very high:

• Imports fall (because goods become expensive).

• That shrinks the tax base.

• Revenue does not scale proportionally.

At extreme levels, tariffs can even reduce revenue — similar to how extremely high income tax rates can reduce taxable income.

For a large economy like the U.S., replacing trillions in income tax revenue with tariffs would likely require:

• Massive import taxes (40%+).

• Major economic disruption.

• Retaliation from trade partners.

• Higher consumer prices.

So while theoretically possible in a narrow sense, it is economically implausible under current U.S. spending levels.

---

2️⃣ Are there countries without income taxes?

Yes — but for very different reasons.

Some countries fund themselves primarily through:

• Natural resource revenues

• State-owned oil exports

• Financial sector revenues

• Tourism

• Sovereign wealth funds

Here are real examples:

🌍 Resource-Rich Countries (Oil & Gas)

• United Arab Emirates

• Qatar

• Kuwait

These countries have:

• No personal income tax (or extremely limited forms)

• Massive oil and gas export revenue

• Relatively small citizen populations

Important caveat:
Many rely on foreign labor and still use other taxes (VAT, fees, corporate taxes).

---

🏝️ Tourism / Financial Centers

• Bahamas

• Monaco

They fund government through:

• Tourism

• Property taxes

• Import duties

• Financial services

• Business registration fees

Again, these are:

• Small countries

• Small populations

• High per-capita wealth or niche economies

---

3️⃣ Why this model doesn’t scale to large economies

Large countries like:

• United States

• Germany

• Japan

Have:

• Large populations

• Expensive social programs

• Military commitments

• Infrastructure costs

• Healthcare systems

• Pension systems

These require broad tax bases — typically:

• Income taxes

• Payroll taxes

• Corporate taxes

• Consumption taxes

Tariffs are simply too narrow and too distortionary to support that scale.

---

4️⃣ Big Economic Tradeoff

Countries without income taxes usually have:

• ✔️ Small populations

• ✔️ Concentrated natural resource wealth

• ✔️ Limited welfare systems

• ❌ Less economic diversification

• ❌ Greater vulnerability to commodity price swings

Oil-rich states can eliminate income tax because oil exports act like a massive external revenue stream. The U.S., by contrast, is a diversified, consumption-heavy economy.

---

Bottom Line

Theoretically possible? Yes — under extreme conditions.
Practically feasible for a large modern economy like the U.S.? Very unlikely.
Do some countries avoid income taxes? Yes — mostly small, resource-rich, or highly specialized economies.

If you’d like, I can also walk through a rough numerical comparison showing how large tariffs would have to be to replace U.S. income tax revenue.