Set back by recession, and shut out of rebound
By: Michael Winerip
Getty Images
Hundreds of job applicants line up at a job fair in New York City.
In September 2012, it appeared that the
world was John Fugazzie's frozen oyster. He was in charge of dairy and
frozen foods for the A.&P. supermarket chain, making $125,000 a
year.
He was also a guest that month at a White House forum on joblessness, in recognition of his work creating Neighbors-helping-Neighbors U.S.A., a volunteer networking organization with 28 chapters in New Jersey serving 1,200 unemployed, mainly white-collar, baby boomers. ''John has one of the best volunteer organizations out there,'' said Ben Seigel, a deputy director at the Labor Department. ''He's tireless and always upbeat.''
Lately Mr. Fugazzie has been feeling a little weary and beat down. One morning last October, just before his 57th birthday, he was laid off and, carrying a box of belongings from his office, driven home in a car service hired by the company. In the 10 months since, he has applied for more than 400 positions and had 10 interviews, but still has no job.
He and his family are living in his 88-year-old mother's home, and last month he awoke at 4:30 a.m., sweating profusely, in the midst of a heart attack.
As happens to many Americans, when he lost his job, he lost his health insurance. He now owes $171,569.44 for the six nights he spent at the hospital.
And so on the evening of Aug. 15, at a meeting of the job club he himself started here two years ago, he told the others he was just like them. ''I need a job,'' he said. ''I need to make money now.''
He was also a guest that month at a White House forum on joblessness, in recognition of his work creating Neighbors-helping-Neighbors U.S.A., a volunteer networking organization with 28 chapters in New Jersey serving 1,200 unemployed, mainly white-collar, baby boomers. ''John has one of the best volunteer organizations out there,'' said Ben Seigel, a deputy director at the Labor Department. ''He's tireless and always upbeat.''
Lately Mr. Fugazzie has been feeling a little weary and beat down. One morning last October, just before his 57th birthday, he was laid off and, carrying a box of belongings from his office, driven home in a car service hired by the company. In the 10 months since, he has applied for more than 400 positions and had 10 interviews, but still has no job.
He and his family are living in his 88-year-old mother's home, and last month he awoke at 4:30 a.m., sweating profusely, in the midst of a heart attack.
As happens to many Americans, when he lost his job, he lost his health insurance. He now owes $171,569.44 for the six nights he spent at the hospital.
And so on the evening of Aug. 15, at a meeting of the job club he himself started here two years ago, he told the others he was just like them. ''I need a job,'' he said. ''I need to make money now.''
Most of the 15 men and women meeting at
the library in this prosperous suburb were middle-aged or older, people
who had worked all their lives, but lost jobs in the recession and its
aftermath and have not been able to get back to where they were. Many of
them worry that they never will, in part because of discrimination by
employers against older workers. (Related: 6 boomer jobs to ride the age wave)
On the statistical surface, boomers seem better off than other age groups. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the unemployment rate for workers 55 to 64 (the category that best matches boomers, who range from 48 to 67) was 5.4 percent in July, compared with 7.4 percent for the general population.
But almost every other number from the bureau makes it clear that while the economy may be improving, a substantial number of older workers who lost jobs—even those lucky enough to be re-employed—are still suffering. Two-thirds in that age group who found work again are making less than they did in their previous job; their median salary loss is 18 percent compared with a 6.7 percent drop for 20- to 24-year-olds.
The re-employment rate for 55- to 64-year-olds is 47 percent and 24 percent for those over 65, compared with 62 percent for 20- to 54-year-olds. And finding another job takes far longer: 46 weeks for boomers, compared with 20 weeks for 16- to 24-year-olds.
More from The New York Times:
Hamptons McMansions herald a return of excess
To protect its empire, ESPN stays on offense
'Revenge porn' could be criminal offense in California
Nor are those who believe age discrimination was a factor likely to have much luck in court. In 2009, just as the economy was hitting rock-bottom, the Supreme Court issued a ruling that toughened the standard for proving bias.
''It's easier for younger workers to bounce back,'' says Mr. Seigel of the Labor Department. ''They don't have many financial obligations. Older workers are supporting families; they may be supporting parents. They can't afford to spend two years going back for a degree to retrain.'' (Related: How to fight age discrimination)
On the statistical surface, boomers seem better off than other age groups. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the unemployment rate for workers 55 to 64 (the category that best matches boomers, who range from 48 to 67) was 5.4 percent in July, compared with 7.4 percent for the general population.
But almost every other number from the bureau makes it clear that while the economy may be improving, a substantial number of older workers who lost jobs—even those lucky enough to be re-employed—are still suffering. Two-thirds in that age group who found work again are making less than they did in their previous job; their median salary loss is 18 percent compared with a 6.7 percent drop for 20- to 24-year-olds.
The re-employment rate for 55- to 64-year-olds is 47 percent and 24 percent for those over 65, compared with 62 percent for 20- to 54-year-olds. And finding another job takes far longer: 46 weeks for boomers, compared with 20 weeks for 16- to 24-year-olds.
More from The New York Times:
Hamptons McMansions herald a return of excess
To protect its empire, ESPN stays on offense
'Revenge porn' could be criminal offense in California
Nor are those who believe age discrimination was a factor likely to have much luck in court. In 2009, just as the economy was hitting rock-bottom, the Supreme Court issued a ruling that toughened the standard for proving bias.
''It's easier for younger workers to bounce back,'' says Mr. Seigel of the Labor Department. ''They don't have many financial obligations. Older workers are supporting families; they may be supporting parents. They can't afford to spend two years going back for a degree to retrain.'' (Related: How to fight age discrimination)
At the Aug. 15 meeting, Barbara Braun,
who worked as a marketing director for a pharmaceutical company, said
she wasn't able to relocate to California when the company moved. ''I
have a mother with Alzheimer's, I think it would have killed her,'' she
said. ''Our lives are full of complications we didn't have at 35.''
They have no doubt that their age is held against them, yet work to keep hopeful. When a woman suggested shaving a decade off her résumé and not posting a photo on networking and job search sites to hide her age, Mr. Fugazzie advised against it. ''When you go to the interview, you're going to look like who you are,'' he said. ''To waste time hiding it when you're only going to lose at the other end makes no sense. If they don't want someone your age, you don't want them.''
What he does recommend is lowering expectations. ''You're not likely to be the department head,'' he said, ''so sell yourself as a team player who will work with younger people and help train them.''
Since the Supreme Court ruling, most lawyers won't even take age discrimination cases. In an effort to change that, a bill has been filed in the Senate each of the past several years, aimed at making it easier to bring a discrimination lawsuit.
The latest legislation has rare bipartisan support; Senator Tom Harkin, Democrat of Iowa, and Senator Charles E. Grassley, Republican of Iowa, are co-sponsors. ''Older Americans have immense value to our society and our economy,'' Mr. Grassley said in a recent news release. ''They deserve the protections Congress originally intended.''
In the last Congress, along with the Democratic majority in the Senate, six Republicans backed the legislation, although two, both moderates, Olympia J. Snowe of Maine and Scott P. Brown of Massachusetts, are no longer in the Senate. Cristina Martin-Firvida, a legislative specialist at AARP, says the bill has the votes to pass the Senate, but to have a chance at becoming law, more Republican senators would need to get behind it, which might then persuade the Republicans who control the House to take up the measure.
At the Ridgewood meeting, people discussed job-hunting strategies. Karen Clements, a paralegal, said she had four résumés ready to go, each emphasizing a different skill: bookkeeping, S.E.C. compliance, fraud investigation and intellectual property rights.
She described a friend who is dressed in business attire by 4 a.m. Mondays, so she'll be ready the moment an opportunity is posted online. If the firm wants to do a Skype interview, said Ms. Clements, her friend is dressed for Skyping. ''By Tuesday they'll have 1,000 résumés and the window will be closed.''
''It's like Wayne Gretzky says,'' Ms. Braun told them: ''You have to skate to where the puck will be.''
They discussed the importance of following up any contact with thank-you e-mails and handing out lots of business cards, though it's tricky to identify yourself when you have no job. ''Be careful of the title you give yourself -- you don't want to sound dated,'' said Ms. Braun, whose business card reads, ''Barbara J. Braun, principal, BarbaraJBraun LLC, Connect Goals to Extraordinary Outcomes.''
They have no doubt that their age is held against them, yet work to keep hopeful. When a woman suggested shaving a decade off her résumé and not posting a photo on networking and job search sites to hide her age, Mr. Fugazzie advised against it. ''When you go to the interview, you're going to look like who you are,'' he said. ''To waste time hiding it when you're only going to lose at the other end makes no sense. If they don't want someone your age, you don't want them.''
What he does recommend is lowering expectations. ''You're not likely to be the department head,'' he said, ''so sell yourself as a team player who will work with younger people and help train them.''
Since the Supreme Court ruling, most lawyers won't even take age discrimination cases. In an effort to change that, a bill has been filed in the Senate each of the past several years, aimed at making it easier to bring a discrimination lawsuit.
The latest legislation has rare bipartisan support; Senator Tom Harkin, Democrat of Iowa, and Senator Charles E. Grassley, Republican of Iowa, are co-sponsors. ''Older Americans have immense value to our society and our economy,'' Mr. Grassley said in a recent news release. ''They deserve the protections Congress originally intended.''
In the last Congress, along with the Democratic majority in the Senate, six Republicans backed the legislation, although two, both moderates, Olympia J. Snowe of Maine and Scott P. Brown of Massachusetts, are no longer in the Senate. Cristina Martin-Firvida, a legislative specialist at AARP, says the bill has the votes to pass the Senate, but to have a chance at becoming law, more Republican senators would need to get behind it, which might then persuade the Republicans who control the House to take up the measure.
At the Ridgewood meeting, people discussed job-hunting strategies. Karen Clements, a paralegal, said she had four résumés ready to go, each emphasizing a different skill: bookkeeping, S.E.C. compliance, fraud investigation and intellectual property rights.
She described a friend who is dressed in business attire by 4 a.m. Mondays, so she'll be ready the moment an opportunity is posted online. If the firm wants to do a Skype interview, said Ms. Clements, her friend is dressed for Skyping. ''By Tuesday they'll have 1,000 résumés and the window will be closed.''
''It's like Wayne Gretzky says,'' Ms. Braun told them: ''You have to skate to where the puck will be.''
They discussed the importance of following up any contact with thank-you e-mails and handing out lots of business cards, though it's tricky to identify yourself when you have no job. ''Be careful of the title you give yourself -- you don't want to sound dated,'' said Ms. Braun, whose business card reads, ''Barbara J. Braun, principal, BarbaraJBraun LLC, Connect Goals to Extraordinary Outcomes.''
How Am I Doing?
Forty-two year old Becky from
Virginia wants to know if her 48-year old partner, Pam can retire from
her physically demanding job at age 55, while Becky continues to work.
Several mentioned the importance of LinkedIn, the business networking site.
''You have to have at least 500 contacts,'' said Lisa Sepetjian, who has been an accounts manager for banks and small-business lenders. ''Any less shows you don't care; you're not in the game.''
Ms. Braun described how she was able to go from 50 LinkedIn contacts to 500 in just a week.
''I'm at 4,200,'' Mr. Fugazzie said.
''I don't want to know 500 people,'' Ms. Sepetjian said. ''But I want people to know I'm not some baby boomer sitting at home eating bonbons.''
At 8:50 p.m., when a librarian announced that it was closing time, many were still networking. Afterward, eight handed me their business cards and several sent follow-up e-mails thanking me for coming.
By 10:30 p.m., even before I got home, the first of 10 follow-up e-mails had arrived from Mr. Fugazzie. Attached were testimonials from five people; copies of four certificates of commendation for Neighbors-helping-Neighbors; and a letter of commendation to the group from the New Jersey governor, Chris Christie, that began ''Dear Friends.''
Also attached was an invitation to a May 16, 2013, meeting at the White House to discuss long-term unemployment, which Mr. Fugazzie hadn't been able to attend. ''I really wanted to go,'' he said. ''I could have made some important contacts, but my youngest son, Tyler, was graduating from the College of New Jersey on the same day and how could I miss that?''
''You have to have at least 500 contacts,'' said Lisa Sepetjian, who has been an accounts manager for banks and small-business lenders. ''Any less shows you don't care; you're not in the game.''
Ms. Braun described how she was able to go from 50 LinkedIn contacts to 500 in just a week.
''I'm at 4,200,'' Mr. Fugazzie said.
''I don't want to know 500 people,'' Ms. Sepetjian said. ''But I want people to know I'm not some baby boomer sitting at home eating bonbons.''
At 8:50 p.m., when a librarian announced that it was closing time, many were still networking. Afterward, eight handed me their business cards and several sent follow-up e-mails thanking me for coming.
By 10:30 p.m., even before I got home, the first of 10 follow-up e-mails had arrived from Mr. Fugazzie. Attached were testimonials from five people; copies of four certificates of commendation for Neighbors-helping-Neighbors; and a letter of commendation to the group from the New Jersey governor, Chris Christie, that began ''Dear Friends.''
Also attached was an invitation to a May 16, 2013, meeting at the White House to discuss long-term unemployment, which Mr. Fugazzie hadn't been able to attend. ''I really wanted to go,'' he said. ''I could have made some important contacts, but my youngest son, Tyler, was graduating from the College of New Jersey on the same day and how could I miss that?''
4 Comments Total
Comments
| cmnsense |
One
of the main reasons these people need a "job" is because they need
health insurance.
If they were covered by socialized medicine they would have so many more
options, they could become self-employed, open they own company, etc.
Lack of socialized medicine also chains others to their jobs. So many
entrepreneurial opportunities are wasted because people can't risk a
chance to leave their dumb 9-5 job because they know if they get sick
they are fukked and so are their families.
Another reason for slow job creation is how expensive employer benefits
are. The money companies spend on benefits is better spent on creating
new jobs.
| donna_summer |
But CNBC says the recession has been over since 2009. Everything is wonderful. Consumers are confident.
How can this be?
| moonmac |
I
see all these older slobs with a huge house, a pool and a speed boat in
their yard.. After talking to them I have no clue how they made it thru
life so easily. Then I call Pizza Hut and the 30 year old who answers
the phone sounds like a Fortune 500 CEO that makes $9 per hour. BIZZARO
WORLD I TELL YOU!!!
Add Comments
Your Comments (Up to 1100 characters):
Remaining characters
1100
CNBC welcomes your contribution. Please respect our community and the integrity
of its participants. CNBC reserves the right to moderate and approve your comment.
Featured
-
Americans' confidence in the economy inched closer to a 5 1/2-year high on optimism that hiring and wages could pick up.
-
President Obama won't negotiate over the debt ceiling, Treasury Secretary Jack Lew tells CNBC.
-
U.S. single-family home prices rose in June though the pace of gains slowed slightly, a closely watched survey showed on Tuesday.
-
Treasury Secretary pressed Congress to allow the government to borrow more money.
